whythawk ratings: measuring effective development

NOTE: To use the advanced features of this site you need javascript turned on.

home arrow aloft: the whythawk blog arrow Should charitable organisations be allowed to compete with businesses?
About Module

Did you know that emerging markets are lucrative investments?

 

Ask Whythawk.

Announce Module
Learn more Introduction to Unlocking the Fortune at the Bottom of the Pyramid
Should charitable organisations be allowed to compete with businesses?
 

By Gavin Chait, on 19 January 2007

Greenpeace T-shirts: competing with poor workers everywhere
Greenpeace T-shirts: competing with poor workers everywhere
Charities and development organisations frequently like to supplement their incomes from donors by selling items.  Some organisations have become major brands in their own right (such as Oxfam or Greenpeace).  Should these organisations continue to be treated as non-profits, and not subject to taxation, if part of their operations generate profits?

It is a difficult question.  The organisations can point to the way in which they use their funds.  But businesses can point out that they are being disadvantaged.  Since development organisations don’t have to pay tax, and many of their inputs are sponsored, their goods can be sold much more cheaply.

Consider the not-too-far-fetched example of a development organisation specialising in sewing training selling its students stock against past graduates of its school.  But at much lower prices, since the fabric, sewing machines and infrastructure are sponsored and the profits aren’t taxed.  They would be working against their own beneficiaries.  Textiles workers are in an especially vulnerable industry and so don't need unfair competition.

While the South African Institute of Chartered Accountants (SAICA) may disagree, the South African Revenue Service has made the correct decision in deciding to tax these profits.  In order that business be a level playing field and development doesn’t become a protected industry.

   
Quote this article in website
Related articles

Keywords : tax, charities, non-profits, sponsored


Users' Comments  
 


Add your comment
Name
E-mail
Title  
Comment
 
Available characters: 600
   Notify me of follow-up comments
  This image contains scrambled text in order to prevent spam.  If you have difficulty reading it then hit the Reload button next to the image.
Enter the characters in the image (case-sensitive):

   
   

No comment posted

< Prev   Next >